It’s Not Laziness: Why Riders Struggle to “Put in the Work” …and How to Help

If you’ve taught riding long enough, you’ve seen it.

A rider who wants to learn… but struggles to put in the “work,” so to speak.
They may be slow to get started, easily distracted, or move through the routine with lackluster effort.

This is especially common when riders are working on the same foundational skills for an extended period of time—which, let’s be honest, is most of riding. Riding is an orchestra that is constructed from a relatively small number of aids, refined over and over again.

Over the years, I’ve come to realize something important:

This is rarely a problem of attitude or discipline.
And I’ll be honest—I used to think “Why won’t they just try harder?”

But it’s not that. More often, it’s a reflection of how motivation and attention actually function in the brain.

In a previous article, Unlocking and Mastering Motivation in Lessons, I explored intrinsic and extrinsic motivation—and how riders are more likely to engage when they feel a sense of autonomy, competence, and connection. Research from psychologists Edward Deci and Richard Ryan shows that when these needs are met, people naturally want to learn and improve.

But motivation is only part of the picture.

Because even when a rider is motivated, they can still struggle to get started or fully engage in the moment.

Especially when:

• • the skill feels repetitive

• • progress is slow or hard to recognize

• • the task requires sustained mental or physical effort

In these situations, the challenge often isn’t desire—it’s activation, attention, and follow-through.

This is particularly relevant for riders with differences in executive function, such as Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), but it’s certainly not limited to riders with a diagnosis.

The truth is, all brains are influenced by how tasks are structured.

And when a task feels repetitive, effortful, or unrewarding, the rider’s attention, effort, and drive will start to break down—even when they genuinely want to succeed.

This is where many instructors get stuck.

“Why won’t my rider put in the work to meet their goals?”

More often than not, it’s not because they’re lazy.
It’s because the lesson isn’t yet set up in a way that supports their focus and drive.

So if attention and activation are the real barriers—not mislabeled attitude or laziness—then our role needs to shift.

It’s not about asking riders to “try harder.”

It’s about designing lessons that make it easier for their brains to create action.

---

 

6 Ways to Direct Focus and Support Engagement

 

1. Connect the Skills to What They Care About

Attention sticks when something feels personally relevant.

When you connect a task to something a rider already enjoys, you give their brain a reason to engage.

What this looks like:

• • Tie the skill directly to their equestrian goals

• • Learn what your riders are interested in—both horse-related and not

• • Find ways to link those interests to what they’re working on

You’re not changing the task.
You’re changing what it means to them.

 

---

2. Create Novelty

The brain is wired to notice what’s new—and horses are, too.

Even a small change can bring attention back online.

What you can do:

• • Change how the skill is practiced (stay tuned for blog on types of practice)

• • Use different games or activities

• • Change the setting—get out of the arena when appropriate

• • Rotate horses when it makes sense

You can also shift focus across lessons:

• • one day on position

• • another on timing

• • another on modulation of aids

• • etc

The skill stays the same.
But the rider is interacting with it in a different way.

 

---

3. Play & Exploration — Make the Skill Feel Less Like Work

Play changes the emotional tone of a task.

When something feels like a game, the brain is far more willing to engage—even if the underlying skill hasn’t changed.

Consider:

• • How can this feel lighter or more enjoyable?

• • How can you reduce the pressure of “right vs. wrong”?

• • How can you encourage exploration?

What this might look like:

• • riding with music

• • letting riders “teach” you (and you follow exactly-and only- what they say)

• • giving the horse a “human voice” narrating the ride

• • allowing space for safe mistakes and experimentation

Same skills. Whole different energy.

 

---

4. Competition: Add Just Enough Challenge

Competition creates focus and clarity.

This doesn’t have to mean pressure—it can be simple and supportive.

Ideas:

• • Rider vs. themselves:
    “Last time you got 3 in a row—can you get 4?”

• • Rider vs. instructor or volunteer:
    “Let’s see who can first identify the correct diagonal.”

• • Small group challenges:
    “Who can hold two-point the longest?”
    “Who can ride the quietest transition?”

The goal isn’t to win.
It’s to give the brain a reason to lock in.

 

---

5. Collaboration and Connection

Connection is powerful—and often underused in lessons.

How can the task become shared?

• • “I’ll hold a squat as long as you hold your two-point.”

• • “I know this trot is bouncy—I have a harder time sitting it too.”

• • “Your volunteer was asking me what it’s like to ride a horse, can you teach them how to use reins?”

When riders feel like they’re part of the process, not just being directed, engagement often increases.

 

---

6. Time Incentives: Use Urgency to Spark Action

Some riders don’t struggle with the skill itself—
they struggle with getting started or staying engaged.

Time creates a boundary.
And with it, a reason to act now.

Examples:

• • “Once you get 4 laps of posting trot, we’ll play a game—the faster you get it done, the more time we have to play!”

• • “For the next 10 strides, give me your absolute best following seat.”

Time turns effort into something immediate and defined.

 

---

What Works Will Vary

There’s no single “right” approach.

These are tools—not rules.

You’ll mix and match based on the rider, based on the day.

•  

And often, combining them is where things really click.

For example, I enjoy having riders help design their own obstacles or patterns—and then challenge them to improve various elements.

---

A Shift in Perspective

When a rider seems “checked out,” it’s easy to assume they’re not trying hard enough.

But I challenge you to assume, it’s not about effort.

It’s about a task their brain is struggling to engage with.

When you layer in:

• • interests

• • novelty

• • play

• • challenge

• • connection

• • and time-based urgency

You create an environment where:

• • attention is easier

• • effort feels more natural

• • and progress can start to build again

And that’s when those “stuck” riders begin to move forward.